How does the Big Picture add-on differ from JIRA Portfolio

I haven't installed this yet to test it out because I am unsure how this is different from JIRA Portfolio.. The description (and PRICE) of this add-on looks so similar, I have to ask.. Can anyone offer an answer??

4 answers

Wanted to update this that I have since gotten some FANTASTIC responses from the authors of the BigPicture plugin.. Will be installing and comparing it to JIRA Portfolio so that my company can make a final decision here.. Will share my findings in case anyone else is searching for this information..

Hi Crystal, In our organization we are currently evaluating BigPicture as well. Can you give us some insight in your evaluation of the two products against each other? Thanks, Jakob

Hi,

Due to high demand, we have prepared an official Confluence dedicated solely to clear comparisons of our products to other Marketplace offerings.

 

https://softwareplant.atlassian.net/wiki/display/COMPARE/

 

It features both a Gantt plugin section (for BigGantt), and a Project Portfolio Management section (for BigPicture). Obviously, if there are any questions we're happy to answer them, this is just for convenience and general overview.

I've been using Portfolio for Jira for a while now, and really love it. However, it does frequently have some scheduling decisions that doesn't make sense, and troubleshooting them is sometimes really frustrating.

In one such frustrating event, I decided to install Bigpicture (all their addons, Gant, Enterprise, the works, as I work in a rather large company).

My feelings were that Bigpicture really tried hard to replicate Microsoft Project. Eventhing they do, related and looked very much like MSP. This said, I found the interface confusing, and I couldn't pick it up easily, in order to get my plan set up and scheduled. It seems like it was just MSP in a website, but without any automated scheduling (which is, to me at least, the one killer feature of Portfolio for Jira, that makes me want to go with it, rather than any other tool). Portfolio for Jira seems to be enhanced really quickly, and I see recently they've been spending time to explain their scheduling decisions better, so I'm guessing it's just a matter of time before they'll improve this enough, so that your troubleshooting becomes less frustrating.

My vote, even if the frustrations included, Portfolio for Jira.

Received this response:

"Hello,

Thanks for contacting us! These 2 plugins are widely different, in fact the only thing they have in common is the "project portfolio management" concept. For starters, BigPicture features best-in-class Gantt charts, which JIRA Portfolio does not even have. The interfaces, modules, workflows and available options are all different in every single detail.

The prices also differ. In fact, none of the prices of these 2 plugins is the same. BigPicture is exactly or nearly twice cheaper than JIRA Portfolio for all licenses excluding the 10-user one.

 

I encourage you to try out BigPicture for yourself to see, as it really is much more than JIRA Portfolio or any other solution on the market - that's precisely why we developed it."

 

Unfortunately this response doesn't REALLY answer my question and only gets me part way to what I need to know..

 

Even IF the Big Picture "interfaces, modules, workflows and available options are all different in every single detail.", I am still not clear based on this response if FUNCTIONALLY this add-on will provide the same benefit that I was looking to get from JIRA Portfolio.. Namely this: A single, accurate view for planning and managing initiatives across multiple teams and projects in JIRA.

Automatic scheduling, capacity planning, and the power to react and change in real time.

 

Hoping someone can provide some thoughtful insight.

Did you get any further clarity? I am also looking for a portfolio mgmt tool for Jira but we are mostly a non-agile shop.

Please see some issues I would feedback on. I'm new to Jira and am trying to work out where to invest my time transferring Gantt charts from old to 1 of these 2 software management tools (I typically use monthly recurring tasks, however software development is now also starting):

Surprisingly permissions and setting due dates have been the most difficult so far.

I think Portfolio for JIRA might have some new age system that is better than Gantt charts, but I don't understand it yet, so need to work with trusty Gantt charts until I receive some help from the Portfolio for JIRA team.

 

BigPicture

Plugin for JIRA. Buggy, didn’t work. $20 10 users. Gantt chart, risk management, resource management and more.

Export to excel (or spreadsheet format, csv) available?

Does this integrate across Portfolio for Jira to see multiple projects/issues/resources/timeframes?


WBS

Gantt-Chart for JIRA. $10 10 users.

Graphics seem basic.

Risks, like BigPicture?

Roadmaps, like BigPicture?

I can’t set a due date?

Does this integrate across Portfolio for Jira to see multiple projects/issues/resources/timeframes?


Support/feedback needed.

Replied on e-mail:

 

WBS is a bit tricky, because it's a competing solution and one that I obviously do not know as good as its authors - though I did have a good long luck at it and personally found it terrible for the following reasons: https://softwareplant.atlassian.net/wiki/display/COMPARE/WBS+Gantt-Chart

Focusing on our tool:


Export to excel (or spreadsheet format, csv) available?
 

Yes. Also to MS Project if needed.

 


Does this integrate across Portfolio for Jira to see multiple projects/issues/resources/timeframes
 

BigPicture does not integrate with JIRA Portfolio, but rather replaces it, as you can create a Program that pulls multiple (or even all) your projects and allows you to manage them.

Yes, I have received good responses from Big Picture who clarified BigPicture, JIRA for Portfolio and WBS. Thanks, working with BigPicture for now.

Would it have any impact on my Jira service and performance  

 

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
How to earn badges on the Atlassian Community

How to earn badges on the Atlassian Community

Badges are a great way to show off community activity, whether you’re a newbie or a Champion.

Learn more
Community showcase
Published May 21, 2018 in Jira Software

How large do you think Jira Software can grow?

Hi Atlassian Community! My name is Shana, and I’m on the Jira Software team. One of the many reasons this Community exists is to connect you to others on similar product journeys or with comparabl...

1,238 views 10 18
Read article

Atlassian User Groups

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find a group

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find my local user group

Unfortunately there are no AUG chapters near you at the moment.

Start an AUG

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local meet up. Learn more about AUGs

Groups near you