Thoughts on adding first class version metadata to questions

Colin Goudie Community Champion Jun 09, 2011

I had some conversations about this at the Partner event @ #Summit11 with mixed results

One thing I've noticed in the old forums and especially the comments area in Confluence documentations for Atlassian's products, is that over time it becomes hard to see if the answers are relavent to the version you are using.

In the comments in Confluence this usually means that you need to read the doc, then scan the entire comment thread to make sure you're not missing anything. Some of this is addressed with the use of spaces in the Confluence but I'm wondering if others feel that overtime the answers here may become a bit hard to navigate?

I'm thinking something like a version slider that the community can adjust to indicate the answer they are adding, editing, viewing is relevant to particular versions.??

Would this be confusing? Should tags just be used? Too hard to maintain? or revolutionary :)

5 answers

1 vote
Colin Goudie Community Champion Aug 07, 2011

I'm going to resurface this idea now that more people are hitting answers.

I am seeing more and more questions come up where people either don't specify the versions they are asking about or they put useless tags on their questions i.e. 3.5, 4.4 etc..

If we were discussing one product here then tags would do but we aren't

I say having a first class citizen field, that is accurately updated with which products and versions are available (Allowing multiple entries) is by far the best way to go to have this site useful in the future.

Hi Colin, just acknowledging I'm seeing your update. I've turned this into a feature request:

I'll keep it in mind for sure. It seems like we could get halfway there with tags (if we use the tag wizard maybe it'd be a bit more structured), but I get that it wouldn't handle the use-case of multiple versions.

Colin Goudie Community Champion Aug 22, 2011

Thanks Jeremy

0 vote
It's a challenge to keep data fresh. One thing is that you can downvote an answer that doesn't work, so if it becomes less relevant, or gets fixed later and something changes, the information can be a bit better groomed. The downside to stamping a version to an answer is similar to the "Affects Version" field in JIRA. That field is a mess. It's notoriously inaccurate - it's usually the version that the bug is reported in, but not an accurate indicator of the start and end to the bug. Basically, I'm also not sure the best way to keep info relevant. I'll stay tuned.
I was going to request this as a feature too. Most of the problems could be solved by keeping it simple, and not trying to make the feature do too much. If there was a subscript for each product-related question saying (for example) "This question was asked about Confluence 4.0", it would give readers a context that at least clues them in to how stale the answers might be, and answerers a chance to avoid giving irrelevant answers.
>but not an accurate indicator of the start and end to the bug. That's exactly the reason why I've seen version fields fail most of the time. In Answers this could be tackled by adding an answer "This is fixed in version 4.3" or "For me this is working in 4.4, looks like they fixed it."
0 vote
Colin Goudie Community Champion Jun 13, 2011

I wouldn't design it so an answer is attributed to a single version though. It should be a range of versions, which could be auto populated from JAC. Some type of range selector on the side of the question/answer.

Using the comments and/or downvoting issues just seems to be the old way of doing things and eventually will be a mess and/or require the reader to hunt through multiple question/answer combos to find their solution.

Suggest an answer

Log in or Join to answer
Community showcase
Louis De Jaeger
Posted yesterday in Off-topic

Friday fun: your best joke

Hi all Lets make this Friday fun really fun and post one (or more) of your best jokes! The joke can be about an Atlassian product, or just a really fun joke you want to share! I’m not the best j...

85 views 2 2
Join discussion

Atlassian User Groups

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find a group

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find my local user group

Unfortunately there are no AUG chapters near you at the moment.

Start an AUG

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local meet up. Learn more about AUGs

Groups near you
Atlassian Team Tour

Join us on the Team Tour

We're bringing product updates and pro tips on teamwork to ten cities around the world.

Save your spot