The plugins are quite different and bringing different features in different look and feels. In my opinion the best approach would be to test both in a dev environment and onboard your testing teams to get their feedback on what's most convenient for them to use.
Pricing might also be a different approach if your budget is limited.
I can tell you that both are well known plugins in the market and are well maintained.
In addition, I don,t want to add more confusion, but there's Xray which is well known and widely used if you want to look at it as well!
Hope this helps.
I am obviously heavily biased here, because I work for Adaptavist. I have used both Zephyr and ATM in the past, and continue to use ATM with some clients.
Mickey is completely right about the approach - it doesn't matter how much I were to tell you "ATM is the best", that would not really help you decide. You need to look for yourself - which product fits your desired processes and reporting best?
I would evaluate all the big names in the Testing category for Jira to find the closest match.
And now, the Adaptavist ATM spiel. There is one big difference between ATM and most of the other test case managers. ATM does not try to use Jira issues to hold test cases directly. This has freed up the developers to work outside the limits of issues, giving them the freedom to do some stuff Zephyr does not do, including
I am sure one of our sales people will tell me off for missing things off that list.
We are faced with the same question in our organisation at the moment. We are planning to use Jira as the ONE tool as are in search of a suitable test management plugin to use together with Jira.
Would be helpful if you can share your experience of the evaluation and the tool that you zeroed in on eventually?
If you are looking for a Test & Requirement management Jira add-on, it may worth to take just 3 mins to have a look at synapseRT Jira-on, you can find a overview introduction video from: https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/com.go2group.jira.plugin.synapse/server/overview
Compare the different tools to choose the correct one from them!
Choosing the right Test Management add-on is important. Maybe you should request demos from the different editors in order to compare their products and challenge them based on your own needs and use cases. Even better, you can get free trials for all of them, if you have a bit more time to invest!
Solutions are evolving quickly and even if there were comparisons (like this one), you have the risk to have them biased or or not up to date.
Good luck for your research!
Thanks for replying. I've read most of the products details, but to take a decision it is always better to hear from other team experience, even if it is biased, I could get use of it.
The comparison you've mentioned is really useful, I searched for more like it.
I’m a designer on the Jira team. For a long time, I’ve fielded questions from other designers about how they should be using Jira Software with their design team. I’ve also heard feedback from other ...
Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!Find a group
Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!
Unfortunately there are no AUG chapters near you at the moment.Start an AUG
You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local meet up. Learn more about AUGs