Create
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Sign up Log in
It's not the same without you

Join the community to find out what other Atlassian users are discussing, debating and creating.

Atlassian Community Hero Image Collage

Why there is no Severity Field for Issue Type Bug?

I am looking for Field Severity for Issue Type Bug but could not found any.

I can create a custom field but it should be pre-defined for bug.

 

4 answers

0 votes


How can you get the custom Severity dropdown to use the priority values(with the colors)? 

Custom fields don't have the functionality of the priority field, so I'm afraid you don't get the colours and icons that priority supports.

0 votes

It is by design - when Mike and Scott were writing "something that works better than Bugzilla or its competitors", they actively decided to drop Severity because people creating issues almost always got it wrong, and it was not of any real use to developers. 

With the provision of custom fields, the people who do find it useful can add it, and should when it's useful for their processes.  But it should not be pre-defined - most Jira users don't need or want it.

That makes sense, @Nic Brough _Adaptavist_ , but I do wonder on why they chose to call the field Priority and not use the term Severity.

Considering that the Priority field values are Major, Minor, etc., people rightly consider that to mark how severe (impact) the issue is.

Priority, meanwhile, relates more to when an issue should be handled, which can be managed by using the backlog ranking, Sprint value, Fix Version, etc.

Your thoughts?

Priority and Severity have very different meanings in English, and I think you have completely understood that.

Severity = how bad is it

Priority = how important it is

Atlassian went for Priority and dumped Severity simply because humans don't understand either of them, but Priority is easier to explain and more useful for sorting.

In fact, neither of these should be presented to the person raising issues.  They're always going to over-rate them.  Priority should be determined by the product owners, and feed into how they rank it.  Severity is useful to know, but is usually highly subjective and needs to be balanced against Impact before it has a lot to say. 

Think "Severity = system unusable" - yep, very severe.  But that's utterly useless without a scale - "system unusable for one person" is severe, but a low priority (and hence rank) when the other 49,999 people in the organisation can use it, it really isn't a priority when the other issue is 20,000 people can't see some information because it's the wrong colour in the display.

Like Oleksii Hlovatskyi likes this

Great points, @Nic Brough _Adaptavist_ , which I agree with.

Indeed, one of the things we do at my work is have regular Bug review meetings to come to agreement on how bad something is, how important it is, and when we think best to dedicate time to fix and verify it.

Thanks for always providing quick and informative information and food-for-thought here in the Atlassian Community!

Joe Pitt Community Leader Jul 02, 2020

@Nic Brough _Adaptavist_ I disagree about severity. I think it is useful to have the reporter say how they perceive the severity. Then if you get lots of issues about the same thing you can see a trend in the user's perception of severity. I agree not presenting priority on the create screen because, as you said, they will overrate it. 

I've found it to be completely useless because different people judge it differently.  That improves when it is explained properly, with a clear set of options that are not arguable, but most places don't do that. 

We shouldn't have to be judging a user's perception (in fact, I don't care about their perception in the slightest), they should be giving me absolute data so I can work with it.  A list of options should be clear enough that you can pick any random issue, and have everyone agree with the severity on it.   Where it does work well is where it's then used to drive a priority calculation, hand in hand with an impact assessment.

Like Lucas Smithbauer likes this
0 votes
Joe Pitt Community Leader Jun 26, 2019

As @Jack Brickey says JIRA doesn't have severity. It uses Priority for that function. I add a severity for bugs and use priority for CR issues. 

0 votes
Jack Brickey Community Leader Jun 26, 2019

Hi @Prashant Neharkar , by default Severity field does not exist. You can certainly add it as a dropdown list single-select.

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
TAGS

Community Events

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find an event

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Unfortunately there are no Community Events near you at the moment.

Host an event

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local event. Learn more about Community Events

Events near you