Users in the Administrator project Role cannot administer project, only JIRA-Admin group members can

Hi all,

I've had a good search and haven't found another issue like this, apologies if I've missed something.

We're just migrated from an on-deman to an internally hosted instance of JIRA, all of which has gone well. I'm now taking the time to address our permissions. We've got a group called jira-administrators (no surprises there...) and the Administrator project role.

I want users in the 'Administrator' project role to be able to administer their own project in terms of being able to add other users to other roles (which is exactly what the role description says it will do). But it doesn't work, only users who are in the jira-administrator group have the ability to administer project roles.

This doesn't seem right but I can't see anywhere that I can enable this, it all seems to be set up correctly in the permission schemes. Has anyone got any suggestions?

2 answers

1 accepted

You need to include this project in the Permission schema of the project.

Add this project role(Administrator) to Administer Projects Permission , then you will get this option.

That is how it is set up currently and it does not work.

In the permission scheme I've got the following project roles against the 'Administer Projects' permission:

  • Project Role (Administrators)
  • Project Role (Product Manager)
  • Project Role (Project Manager)
  • Project Role (QA Administrator)

No need to comment on our awful role setup either, I'm working on that ;-)

Check that the people who should have admin rights definitely are in the right role in the project

Check that your permission scheme is definitely associated with the right project

I'm also slightly uncertain about your language - you say "only users who are in the jira-administrator group have the ability to administer project roles " which is absolutely correct - only system-administrators can add/remove roles. All your project-administrators can do is add and remove other users from those roles in their projects

(There's nothing particularly wrong with your role setup, although I don't know your business and I'd tend to try to keep the project admins down to just explicitly "admins" - I don't find product managers and QA really know how to run projects in Jira terms)

Thanks Nic,

Apologies for the confusing terms, you're right - I got some of them mixed up there, let me try and explain again.

We have a group called jira-administrators (like most people I assume) - they have admin rights to the whole of JIRA. What I want is people in specific roles within a project to be able to administer elements of their projects.

For instance, someone in the Project Role - QA Administrator has the ability to manage project roles (which is set correctly within the permission scheme and that permission scheme is applied to the project). The problem is, there is no link to click on to allow this user to administer the project (I'm assuming this functionality would be accessed by the "Administration" link in the top right?).

Does that help explain things better?

I'm sorry, I didn't explain this well enough, and I think you've not grasped what I was asking. Jira-administrators is clear, that's fine, it's "people within a specific role within a project to be able to administer elements of their projects". I am not clear whether you are asking about administration of roles, or users.

I'll try by example. Pick a user (Bob). Bob is not in the Jira-administrator group. You go into project XYZ and add Bob into the QA-Administrator role.

Bob should now have the right to maintain other users, by adding/removing them in the roles for that project. (Bob may also administrate components, versions and Greenhopper settings etc). Bob does not get the right to change roles or project permissions.

Does that sound right?

Assuming I've got that right, then yes, Bob should now have an admin link. Can you get Bob to go to a project summary (http://yourjira/browse/projectshortcode), make sure the summary tab at the top is selected and then look at the top right of that panel and see if he has the "administrate project" cog?

Good, sorry it took a while to get the information straight in my head.

It does sound like you've got everything set up correctly, so the next step, if possible, is to look at Bob's view and check the admin cog. Make sure Bob is looking at a project he is admin on, of course!

The scenario with Bob is exactly what I'm after - I want the QA's and Product Managers (roles) to be able to manage the members in project roles. Their relevant procject roles currently have the permissions to do this but it seems to me like only members of the Jira-Administrators group actually have the ability to change role members.

We're on the same page now 100% - I'm going to do some investigation and I'll get back to you if this doesn't work to see if you have any other ideas, I'm all out of them at the momement.

Mmm, useful, but it would be better to fully understand permissions first, especially as this one appears to be a missing permission rather than one that we can't work out why the person has it (which that plugin is really good at!)

Thanks Nic. I will add an analyzer to tell you what you should do to have a certain permission :)

Ohh, that would be very nice. :-)

Suggest an answer

Log in or Join to answer
Community showcase
Sarah Schuster
Posted Jan 29, 2018 in Jira

What are common themes you've seen across successful & failed Jira Software implementations?

Hey everyone! My name is Sarah Schuster, and I'm a Customer Success Manager in Atlassian specializing in Jira Software Cloud. Over the next few weeks I will be posting discussion topics (8 total) to ...

3,104 views 13 19
Join discussion

Atlassian User Groups

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find a group

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find my local user group

Unfortunately there are no AUG chapters near you at the moment.

Start an AUG

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local meet up. Learn more about AUGs

Groups near you
Atlassian Team Tour

Join us on the Team Tour

We're bringing product updates and pro tips on teamwork to ten cities around the world.

Save your spot