It's not the same without you

Join the community to find out what other Atlassian users are discussing, debating and creating.

Atlassian Community Hero Image Collage

Resource/Capacity Planning in JIRA possible?

Tudor Hofnar Nov 19, 2012

I'm trying to see if there is a way to setup Resource Planning in JIRA. Maybe there is a plugin?

Basically I need a way to limit the amount of issues added to a sprint in GreenHopper. So for example if we have 5 developers and 1 goes on vacation, the sprint should know this and limit the amount of issues we add (based on the hour estimate) since we have 1 less developer...

Is there any way to achieve this in JIRA/GreenHopper or a plugin?

Thanks! (JIRA, OnDemand, GreenHopper)

15 answers

1 accepted

12 votes
Answer accepted
Chris Pettigrew Apr 29, 2013

??? Renjith, I think you are confusing a few things. For starters, planning poker estimates story points based on the level of complexity for stories. Team leaves should never be taken into account at this level because 'level of complexity' has nothing to do with the hours of work your team members are putting in for a given sprint. If we deem something has a story point value of 5, it doesn't suddenly become an 8 simply because I am taking 3 days off during the next sprint. Have you actually been involved in Agile software development before? Teams story point out the level of complexity for each story (initially). They then take that story and break it down into individual tasks for which actual time values are placed against them. Those tasks are then assigned to developers to fill up the total days allocated in a given sprint. The challenge that everybody is trying to solve is: Given a bunch of tasks that each have an hourly assignment to them, with GreenHopper, I have to manually tally up the hourly tasks that I assign to each developer to ensure I don't overshoot, say their 40 hour work week.

As you may have noticed, there have been a number of posts asking about this, and you have, for some reason, shot down every request to deal with resource planning. I'm not sure if you have reviewed your competitor's products, but to say this 'doesn't belong in an Agile development tool' couldn't be further from the truth. Your primary competitors, namely, VersionOne and Microsoft TFS BOTH have this functionality in it. Don't get me wrong, I am a proponent of Atlassian, but to simply say 'this is out of scope of GreenHopper' is being completely ignorant to the users of your product.

Paul Alexander Apr 29, 2013

Chris' comment here is so very spot on:-). While I am still actually buried in work today, I took time to re-read this thread and his comment. Having just done 5 sprint planning sessions on Fri, I can't begin to tell you how vitally critical it is to get capacity planning, at least to some degree, incorporated into GH. I have a scribe with me who tallies up each resource's hours and we must keep doing so until we get each member's capacity satisfied...of course, with some padding baked in for unplanned work.

This is part of any forward planning effort. As a long time TFS user, this concept is very much NOT NEW. If the GH team does not see value in this, please help us understand how you do this in your sprint planning sessions today.

It's nighmare-ish, to say the least, getting a count on each resource's hours...and it all depends on who owns the parent issue and the subtasks. Before any good team starts a sprint, doing this exercise is critical if we expect to meet the committment and progressively see a steady downward burndown. I, too, am a huge fan of the Atlassian products, but I don't get it on this particular capability. Again, if we are not supposed to do this effort here, where do you do it? And at what time?

Lastly, I respect that some Agile teams do not use hours as the estimation value - they sign up for enough stories for their expected velocity, and they attempt to meet that me, this is purely a guess and doesn't provide the kind of metrics I need for my teams' growth and improvement (e.g., burndown (will we actually meet the committment based on hours remaining?, are my task estimates high or low?, etc). So, I don't want to hear someone suggesting that we just do the task level planning after we "start the sprint" in GH...this defeats everything IMO.

Like Deb Shapiro likes this
Renjith Pillai Nov 11, 2013

Hey Chris,

My comment was not say that is not something which is important. I do agree that it an important aspect of any project and if JIRA Agile (a.k.a GreenHopper) was facilitating that it will be great. My comment was that, the current features or development is not aiming to cover that segment at the moment.

And to answer if I have done Agile software development before, yes, right from 2007 :)

Nik Shornikov Sep 24, 2014

Okay, that was a rhetorical question... the real rhetorical questions is, have you been involved in Agile development before where sprints with half the devs on vacation were successfully treated like sprints with everyone on deck? Actual question: what do you mean by "current"? It's almost a year later.

2 votes
Matt Hart Jun 30, 2013

I've created a combination of fields, a report, and an Excel spreadsheet to enable capacity planning with JIRA.

Fields: added Estimated Hours and Hours Remaining to technical task/sub-task - basically our tasks in a story.

Report: I have a report I run that has these columns:

Summary | Key | Est Hours | Hours Remaining | Assignee | Sprint

The report is: "project = EM AND issuetype in (subTaskIssueTypes()) AND Sprint = 44 ORDER BY assignee ASC, key DESC"

In the Excel spreadsheet, I have 2 fixed sheets plus 1 for each team member. One sheet is simply labeled "JIRA". I run the above report, export to Excel (current columns), then copy/paste the entire report into that sheet. The second sheet is the capacity worksheet, containing sprint start/end, holidays, number of ideal work hours, plus planned sprint activity hours (like standups, planning, retro, demo).

Then I have a line entry for each team member with % capacity, days off, est hours, hours remaining, workload capacity. The hours fields link to each member's sheet.

Finally, I wrote a VBA Excel macro that reads the JIRA sheet and adds each team member's line item to their sheet, causing an automatic calculation back on the capacity spreadsheet. Works like a charm - we now do our standups directly from the worksheet, as it shows each persons work and is easy to see how things are going. The workload number is exactly what I needed to make capacity planning with JIRA work correctly - basically it's similar to Rally's Team Member viewpoint in a Sprint, plus the automatic calculation of available hours (that you have to enter manually into Rally).

Excel screenshot

Matt Hart , could you share your spreadsheet? Thanks!

Maurice McCabe Feb 10, 2014

I would like to see it too.

Alicia McLain May 07, 2015

Me too

Herman Burema Jun 03, 2015

Can you share this solution of yours with me, I like to experiment to fit our JIRA implementation.

Suresh Moorthy Dec 17, 2015

Can you please share the spreadsheet?

mamta rathi Dec 01, 2016


Can you please share your excel sheet which will be really helpful

Try this add on: It allow users to configure resource capacity, leaves, working days, public holidays, and displays work allocation charts - in a nutshell - everything you need for Sprint capacity planning and tracking.

I worked with couple of scrum masters earlier who were using similar spreadsheets. But all of them and their teams complained about too much of manual effort and maintainability hassle. Then why not to use an add on which does the job for you faster, automatically and more elegantly!



1 vote

If you want the system to reject your action when adding an issue to the Sprint, based on some arbitrary parameter, then you would need a plugin for that sort of power.

With an OnDemand instance, there isn't a way to prevent adding an issue to the board but this tutorial explains how folks tend to plan and track changes in GreenHopper with a team.

1 vote
Renjith Pillai Jan 11, 2013

In fact I consider this as out of scope of GreenHopper. The way it should happen, IMHO, is that the team do the sprint planning, estimate using poker cards, and the results get into green hopper. Also in this process the leaves of team members are taken into consideration. The actual process of estimation is not really with green hopper. And once started, the burn down will tell where the team is.

James Sandlin Nov 11, 2013

So what you are saying is we should pay thousands of dollars for GreenHopper aka Agile just so we can turn around and continue using stickie notes for planning? If I'm using poker cards (stickie notes) for planning, I may as well keep the scrum board with columns on the board with stickie notes. Oh well... no need for GreenHopper.

1 vote
Nimitt Desai May 28, 2013

Capacity planning clearly belongs to GH. I keep searching for a plug in for capacity planning because I need to maintain this annoying spreadsheet sprint after sprint.

1 vote
James Sandlin Oct 28, 2013

Classic Planning board provided this capability. I could plan, knowing the workload of each member. I still cannot believe Atlassian is not providing a replacement. Is it in the schedule?

Paul Alexander Nov 19, 2013

Yes, please, this on the schedule? Is there an issue you can point us to in your dev backlog? I'm still suprised so few are here discussing this. What are folks doing to compensate? I really need to avoid spending another $3K/year to add the Tempo plugin, which may or may not provide this level of capacity planning. I don't have a test on-demand instance so really not interested in taking tempo for a test drive and having to explain to my population what all of that functionality is there for as I attempt to validate the product's form and function.

1 vote
James Sandlin Apr 29, 2014

Sad that we now much purchase yet another plugin to implement features which existed in Greenhopper Classic.

Atlassian is not listening to users, rather creating a system where we must purchase JIRA + Greenhopper + Even more plugins.

1 vote


If you are using JIRA cloud instance, then check out this useful add on:
It allow teams to configure resource capacity, leaves, working days, public holidays, and displays work allocation charts - in a nutshell - everything you need for Sprint capacity planning and tracking.



Scott Fawcett Jan 15, 2019

New Jira user here (after 10 years with TFS).  We need to pay for a feature that's required for sprint planning?  And competitors provide it as base functionality.  Very odd!!

Like # people like this
0 votes
Dicky Sum Apr 30, 2013

My company is switching from TFS to JIRA GH and I also wonder why there is no resource management for setting developer's capacity. GH gives me the ability to set renmaing hours for the tasks, yet it doesn't have the feature to ensure I don't over assign too many tasks to the developers. Even if I only use story point to plan, I will need to figure out a new velocity if the team member changes.

Paul Alexander Apr 30, 2013

Atlassian, is there a related story in the Atlassian backlog to address capacity/resource planning? Or is there anything similar in your backlog that we could review for consideration? I guess I could look for myself; just wondering...

More importantly, this thread is pretty small. What are others out there doing to compensate? I am very curious.

0 votes
Dicky Sum Apr 30, 2013

My team just finish the sprint planning first time using GH. One of the developers from another department wrote a little tool that calculate our capacity similar to TFS. Then we have a write board were the manager manually tally the hours each time when a task is assigned. Kind of a pain to do this manually. but at least we won't over commit.

0 votes

I recommend you take a look at the Tempo Planner -

0 votes

Matt Hart , could you share your spreadsheet? Thanks!

0 votes
Martin Suntinger Apr 23, 2014

Just came across this thread: We had the same problem for years, and finally decided to build an add-on that really solves this challenges and saves you from manual capacity planning work.

Here's more details:

And a short screencast video:

Would be great to get your feedback on this!

Note: It's currently available for JIRA Download only, OnDemand coming soon.

Martin Suntinger Apr 28, 2014

Thanks for the feedback, Paul! We'll do our best to get it quickly on OD!

Paul Alexander Apr 28, 2014

Very interesting and what appears to be a well done implementation providing what looks to be a lot of high value-add. Can't wait for OnDemand! Kudos and thanks.

0 votes
Paul Alexander Apr 29, 2014

I think I posted in another few related questions here on the answers board...may be worth repeating here though.

The workaround I employ with my teams is to setup a dashboard in Atlassian using the Workload Pie gadget. In my instance, our subtasks contain the work estimates in hours. So, I create a filter like the below to locate all subtasks sitting in un-started sprints against Agile boards in all projects owned by A-Team. Using this pie graphic, we quickly bring in sufficient subtasks for everyone to get them up to their capacity for the sprint. I use ~50hrs per two-week sprint per resource (leaving 30 hrs per sprint for unplanned production support, morning standups, and end-of-sprint retrospectives). Once happy with the distribution, you start the sprint(s).

category = A-Team AND
issuetype in subTaskIssueTypes() AND
Sprint in futureSprints()

I should note that the business folks have already identified the Stories we will take on for the next sprint. We identify any gaps in workload by assigning additional, critical production support issues to get resources up to their capacity.

0 votes
Dwight McPeak Apr 30, 2014

Capacity planning is something we did in painful ways back when we still used waterfall as our development process. If the question we are trying to answer is "Are all of the developers busy during the sprint?" then the answer is always yes. There is always something to do.

Sizing is how much work is there to do. "Populate three fields on the page from the database" would always be the same size for the team.

Estimates are how long it will take a particular person on the team to do that work. You get a different estimate depending on who picks up that particular task. Right now we are not bothering with individual estimates.

We size all of our stories and fill up a sprint based on our velocity. We break up the stories into sub-tasks with the guideline that no sub-task should take anyone on the team more than a day to complete. That way we expect to always see movement each day during our scrum.

We do NOT pre-assign the work. Whenever a developer finishes a sub-task, they go back to the board and start at the top of the list which is still in priority order and they find the next available sub-task and put their name on it. That sub-task might be a code review or documentation or testing or actual coding. You never know what you might get. It’s part of being on a multi-skilled team. We have members from our QA department embedded in the team. It doesn’t mean they are the only ones that test or write test scenarios.

The effect of always pulling work from the highest priority story is that the highest priority work gets done. We don’t have 10 stories that are all 90% done, we have 9 stories that are 100% done and 1 story that rolls to the next sprint.

If we get ahead we can pull the next story from the top of the backlog that has already been approved to work during our backlog refinement meetings.

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
This widget could not be displayed.
This widget could not be displayed.
Community showcase
Published in Jira

Try Jira Cloud for Outlook: Organize your work without leaving your inbox

Hi Atlassian community, My name is Max and I work on the product integration team at Atlassian. I am pleased to announce the early access program for the Jira Cloud add-in for Outlook. This add-in...

2,448 views 6 15
Read article

Community Events

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find an event

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Unfortunately there are no Community Events near you at the moment.

Host an event

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local event. Learn more about Community Events

Events near you