It's not the same without you

Join the community to find out what other Atlassian users are discussing, debating and creating.

Atlassian Community Hero Image Collage

How can I make only certain statuses in a workflow available to certain project roles

We have the Default Software Workflow which is perfect for half of the team (Developers). They HAVE to move through each of these statuses/steps. 

Example:  they must go from "To do" to "In Progress" and from "In Progress" to "Read for Review"  

The other half of the team (Systems Engineers) do not need to move through these steps

Example: They can go from "To do" to "In Review"

 

If I use the Project Role Condition Transition, it means that those roles are allowed to transition from the one status to the next but it does not force them to.

2 answers

1 vote
Joe Pitt Community Leader Sep 12, 2019

You identified the project role condition so what I'm hearing is you want a way to FORCE the users to go through the workflow rather than just do the work and not track it in the workflow.  This is a training and management issue, not a technical one. A couple days off without pay may encourage them to do their job.  

The word FORCE was maybe not the right one, rather I want to remind them which step comes next. I know I have seen somewhere that you can have only the applicable next status available for selection. 

Example: when someone is in "In Progress" state and they want to move on, instead of all the states being available in the dropdown, only the next state which you have stipulated in your workflow is available. So if you are a developer "Ready for Review" will be available and if you are an engineer "In Testing" will be available to you.

I agree that this is a training/management issue, but I have seen this on JIRA (just don't know how to do it) before so if I can help them to get into that habbit it would be great.

Joe Pitt Community Leader Sep 13, 2019

If you setup the conditions on the workflow there will usually only be one possible workflow to execute. I've seen a couple that allowed a branch the user picked, but that is rare

1 vote

There's no way to "force" a human do something in a workflow.  You can stop them doing things they should not, but the day anyone tries to force me to do something is the day I tell them to <insert your own bad things here>

You should create an environment that encourages people to do it the right way.  Don't say "you must", but say "you do realise that if you don't do this, the management reporting will pick you up as not having done any work" or "our users, who pay the bills, need to know where we are with stuff".  Make it their best interest to report accurately, don't mandate.

Your use of conditions to allow people who should be able to do stuff is already correct.  I'm not sure what else you might be asking for>

Hi Nic

Thank you for your response. As mentioned to @Joe Pitt , the word force was maybe not the right one, rather I want to remind them which step comes next.

These are actually workflows they have decided on individually. The dev team decided which states they needed and the Engineering team wanted different states. It is more to help them know which comes next as they are all new to Agile/SCRUM and JIRA.

Using the allow conditions doesn't really help, example:

I can allow a developer to transition from "In Progress" to "Ready for Review" and I can allow an engineer to transition from "In Progress" to "In Testing" but that means that a developer can still go from "In Progress" to "In Testing" and an engineer can still go from "In Progress" to "In Review"

Ok, so I am now a little stuck on what the question is.  You've made use of conditions to say "only person type X can do action Y", it just sounds like you need some more of them - for example one on the "in progress to in testing" that only allows testers to do it, and not the developers

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
Community showcase
Posted in Jira

Demo Den Ep. 7: New Jira Cloud Reports

Learn how to use two new reports for next-gen projects in Jira Cloud:  Cumulative flow diagram and Sprint burndown chart. Ivan Teong, Product Manager, Jira Software, demos the Cumulative ...

363 views 1 3
Join discussion

Community Events

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find an event

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Unfortunately there are no Community Events near you at the moment.

Host an event

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local event. Learn more about Community Events

Events near you