I have created a user group for each project and each project has a permission scheme assigned to it. Now, there is a new jira user who needs to have only read access/view-only access to all the projects and issues within them. This new jira user should not be able to create, edit tasks, add comments in the tasks and make any changes in the projects. In the permission scheme I assigned only one permission - Browse projects to the new user to achieve this requirement. But the new jira user is able to create a new tasks in the projects.
Hello @Mohit Edupuganti
Yes, this is possible, but the confusion comes from where Jira actually decides who can create issues.
Think of Jira permissions like multiple doors.
You closed one door (the permission scheme), but another door is still open.
Even if you only gave the user “Browse projects”, Jira will allow issue creation if the user gets that permission from anywhere else.
Most common reasons:
The user is still in a project role (Users, Developers, Members, etc.)
That role still has Create issues permission
The user is added automatically via default project roles
In Service Management projects, the portal can allow creation outside the permission scheme
So the permission scheme alone doesn’t tell the whole story.
What usually fixes it:
Remove the user from all project roles
Create a dedicated role like Read-only
Give that role only:
Browse projects
Double-check with Permission helper
Once the extra role or group is removed, the user will instantly lose the ability to create issues.
The new user is not in any of the project roles. I have created a separate named read-only and assigned the group browse projects permission in the permission scheme.
You must be a registered user to add a comment. If you've already registered, sign in. Otherwise, register and sign in.
Yes as it should be.
New user is not included in any of the project roles, unless you add to group and that group has project role assigned in project,
You must be a registered user to add a comment. If you've already registered, sign in. Otherwise, register and sign in.
You must be a registered user to add a comment. If you've already registered, sign in. Otherwise, register and sign in.