It's not the same without you

Join the community to find out what other Atlassian users are discussing, debating and creating.

Atlassian Community Hero Image Collage

What happened to responsive table widths?

In the new editor, I cannot find any way to change a table's properties so that it's width is set by its contents.  In the "classic" Confluence page editor, there was an option to select Fixed width or Responsive.  I could create a wonderfully small table for things like short text values.  Now, I am forced to have a giant table no matter what I do.

As a workaround, I can put a table into a set of 3 columns but that's messy.

10 answers

I rely on Confluence every day for work. I honestly thought the classic table editor was the best I've ever used.

The new table editor looks sleeker but is just plain cumbersome compared to the power of the old table editor toolbar.  It's a real shame.

Please please please bring back responsive-width tables!

PS I am using the old editor, and even when set as responsive width, the table goes to full width after publishing

second to that . i  find the new table very annoying

Like # people like this

I can just strenghen what others here complain about. Not being able to adjust the width of columns feels like MS word in the 80s. 

 

It should be easy to re-activate something that was there and went well, isn't it?

I can't make a simple table with fix column width and horizontal scroll...
All docs and examples are pointing on old editor.

It looks like there's a feature request logged here, currently gathering interest: https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/CONFCLOUD-67748

Thanks, Alex.  For everyone else watching this community page, please go add your two cents (vote, watch, and comment) on that actual issue!

Get your co-workers to vote too ;)

And it turns out that that issue is no longer what I thought it was (the title's been changed, too).  So I either need to find the proper issue that matches my question or create one.  Either way, I'll post a link here.

I gave up looking and created a new one:

https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/CONFCLOUD-69352

Please vote on this issue!

Like Alex_Dopp likes this

I am currently having to redo a complicated table I already made in the new editor in the old editor. Since the tables are no longer responsive, all of our users who only have laptops are not able to see the entire table. This is absurd.

For everyone on this thread, please vote for the following issue about this problem!

https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/CONFCLOUD-69352

(Please do not bother adding +1 messages to the issue as Atlassian ignores those; they only care about Votes on issues.)

0 votes
Davin_Studer Community Leader Feb 27, 2019

Unfortunately, that's not possible with the new editor right now. Are you still able to create pages with the old editor? If so I would use that.

Yeah, but the old editor (assuming we're both on the same page) does not have the same page layouts. The whole package is a nightmare....

Like # people like this

I was afraid that would be the answer.  Yes, we can still use the old editor, for now.  Since that is going to be replaced by the new one soon, I'm not counting on that as a long term fix.

I also tried the following "workaround" to get a thinner table:

  1. Create columns (such as a 3 column layout)
  2. Put the table in the middle column

While it looks good in the preview, the width shrinks significantly when publishing the page, so it really smashes the table too tight.

I also tried with a 2 column layout and that seems to suffer the same issue, only less so.  It's as if the two columns are squeezed width-wise and then the set of two columns is centered (I stuck some simple text in the other column and it was obvious that the available space for the table in one column and the text in the other diminished greatly upon publishing).

philoye Atlassian Team Feb 28, 2019

We recently released a fix for the shrinking table inside columns. Sorry that you were affected by this.

Like Zak_Laughton likes this

Well, I'm an author who has spent several hours, days, weeks etc.. not being able to a) select responsive b) being stuck with column widths that are just plain silly. Who checked this (not so cheap) product out? I've got a long.. long document in Confluence that looks like crap and its taken a mountain of formatting (limitations) to get it looking anywhere reasonable. Sorry does not cut it with me!

BTW(2) if I see one more damn badge I'm gonna scream!

Like # people like this

This is also a problem for me, and a clear missing functionality from the new editor. It's a real shame as the new table editor function is nice, but incomplete. Can we please get a fix for this.

Like # people like this

Also for us the missing possibility to define the width of tabel coluns in the new editor is a big drawback compared to what was possible before. I'm wondering, who at Atlassian decided to force cloud users on the new editor eventhough many of the prevouosly available features are still missing!

Like # people like this

'coz it's cheaper....

Is there an update for this yet? Or a timeline?

Like # people like this

Any update one when we can define a fixed width table???

Like # people like this

These tables are causing me no end of problems. Not being able to have responsive tables is unbelievable, it's like going back 10 years in technology - you know Atlassian, people use mobiles and tablets to view pages too!

The biggest issue for me though is when I try and print a page (print to PDF but export to PDF breaks tables too), tables are cropped. This is a huge problem as I share docs with clients via pdf because we can't have hundreds of clients logging into our Confluence.

The old auto column width based on content and page width was so much better.

Like # people like this

I need to strengthen all the arguments said above. The old table editor was kind of genius, simple and powerful. The new one is a pain to use and the not-responsible width is just a step back. Kindly reinvent the wheel here - thanks!

Like # people like this

This is absolutely ridiculous. I've set up Confluence for a client. So, because it is a new subscription, I am being forced to only use the new editor. Client is not impressed at all by the tool.

Confluence Cloud is already missing basic functionality (such as copying a page tree), but now they are forcing us to use an editor that lacks even the most basic functionality???

It actually feels like Atlassian is actively trying to drive customers away. I am at a complete loss trying to understand their thinking.

Like # people like this

It's been a year @philoye

It shows in the animated gif on the Confluence Editing Improvements page Tables section that there is a double-ended arrow icon to the right of the table that allows you to change between Wide, Full-Width, and Fixed-Width, but I don't see that icon in my editor. How can I get that icon to show up?

There are two sets of arrow buttons.  One appears at the top of the page and it makes the entire page either full-width or fixed width (narrow and centered).  The other appears at the top right of a table, but only if the page is set to fixed width.
 
If the page is set to fixed-width, then tables have the option to go wide, full, or centered.  If the page is set to full-width, tables automatically go to full-width as well with no option to change.
 
It's a very strange design choice because you have the option of having your page narrow and centered with tables extending far outside the margins of the rest of the page.  Looks weird to me.

The Atlassian team needs to realize that when they change or remove functionality they destroy any consistency their customers have put into their documents.  Now you can't indent within tables using the new editor either.  I'm not sure what Atlassian has against indentation, because indent functionality was removed and restored not so long ago and it's something I make use of heavily.

Like # people like this

Thanks for the explanation. You're right, I do have my pages set to full width. I don't get why Atlassian thinks it's better to scroll horizontally in a table than to just wrap the text so it's all in view. GAH!

Like James Ingham likes this

Confluence table handling is definitely going the pan.   Seems they want to sell to small children now.   Apart from not being able to set the width, in years gone by you could have nested tables.  And if remember correct;y, you could set the row height too, 
This determined march backwards is as bizarre as it is frustrating.

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
TAGS
Community showcase
Posted in Confluence

What project did you transition or start on Confluence with the shift to remote work?

It’s been great to hear from fellow users over the last few weeks about the best tips and fun moments you’ve had working on Confluence since the transition to working remote. I’d love to keep the c...

159 views 3 8
Join discussion

Community Events

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find an event

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Unfortunately there are no Community Events near you at the moment.

Host an event

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local event. Learn more about Community Events

Events near you