It's not the same without you

Join the community to find out what other Atlassian users are discussing, debating and creating.

Atlassian Community Hero Image Collage

⏰Would page *read time* be helpful for you in Confluence? Edited

droo Atlassian Team Feb 24, 2020

👋Hi there, I'm a designer on Confluence and would love to hear your opinion about read time. (Imagine, for example, something like "6 minute read" shown below a page title).

Would you find it helpful to know about how big a page is or how long it'll take to read?

When would you find this helpful? (Eg. When a page has just been published? When you're comparing different pages? When you're scrolling through blogs? When a page has been shared with you?)

🙏

5 comments

JimmyVan Community Leader Feb 24, 2020

Yes. I use Pocket all the time, and it indicates the length of how long it predicts it will take a page to be read. If it's short, I will probably read it now. If it's long, I'll snooze the tab/save to Pocket or somehow remind myself to read long content later.

It's helpful when I first encounter the content, so as soon as the page loads, at the top, under the title, along with author, it'll give me an indicative guide. Would also be helpful in email notifications, so when page is published/I'm mentioned in a comment on a page I am not watching

Like droo likes this

No. Super-unhelpful for me. I maintain a technical manual with pages that vary between quick process guides (200-300 words) and in-depth analysis (15,000-30,000 words). My Google analytics show that no-one ever reads the in-depth pages from end to end - instead, even for 30,000 word pages they spend on average 3-5 minutes, suggesting that they are skimming the table of contents to identify the bit that's important for them. 

Like # people like this

@droo  On paper this sound like a great idea, but this won't work for all users.

For example, if I'm writing a blog on Confluence, features like this are good to have. But if I'm writing KB or product documentation this will have no use. Because, only casual readers of casual content like blog post are interested beforehand how much time certain read will take. Not the KB readers.

"Medium - https://medium.com " has this feature and I only take a glance at 'time to read' if I'm reading some theoretical articles about random things which might help me someday but not immediately helpful. But when I'm reading a post which came to me via google search (and is immediately helpful and needed), I never pay attention to 'time to read'.

Screenshot 2020-02-25 at 2.37.28 PM.png

 

But if you find lots of people interesting in this, make sure you implement in it in non intrusive way just like in image above.

 

P.S. Create a discussion type post for such recommendations, not question. :-)

Like # people like this

Hi @droo 

It depends where it will be used and whether it can be turned on or off for documents, given different pages of importance. A KB post versus a process page. I wouldn't want a user put off reading a process page because it says 10 min read. 

@RPT_Admin You mentioned Google Analytics, do you have this on your confluence pages? if so, is it possible to have it on a Confluence page on the cloud? We have our technical manual or user guide for our software on the Customer Portal and are very keen to know who is reading it, how long they are reading it, what pages they are reading? 

Like droo likes this

We use Google Analytics in Confluence. It's a free plugin for Confluence Cloud. Don't expect the analytics to be as useful as you would get from a regular website because Atlassian limits the amount of data available to Google. But you can track page views and durations, amongst other things.  

Like # people like this

Thanks @RPT_Admin - I'll check that out. 

Sharon_Helms Community Leader Feb 25, 2020

I'm also in the "No" camp for this feature, here's why:

  • Read time is based on assumptions about the average reading speed of an average adult -- are those assumptions inclusive?  We serve a large, diverse population who read at many different speeds. Some are using screen readers, some have cognitive disabilities, some read English as their second or third language, some are in stressful situations. In short, read time varies and we're working hard to be an inclusive organization. Features like this are not ones we would want to have on our pages. At the very least we'd really want to be able to opt-out.
  • +1 on the comments about technical content being different than blog content. The way people read knowledge base articles such as procedures is very different than "thought pieces" about leadership on a company blog. Maybe just bring this feature to blog posts?
Like # people like this

Comment

Log in or Sign up to comment
Community showcase
Published in Confluence Cloud

Convert your old pages to the new editor

Hey Community 👋, Following the recent release of the new editor, we will be releasing the ability for users to convert existing pages from the legacy editor to the new editor. We’ve been resp...

6,528 views 44 29
Read article

Community Events

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find an event

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Unfortunately there are no Community Events near you at the moment.

Host an event

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local event. Learn more about Community Events

Events near you