It's not the same without you

Join the community to find out what other Atlassian users are discussing, debating and creating.

Atlassian Community Hero Image Collage

jira filter != doesn't find empty values

Hi all,

When I create a filter where field != value, the results do not show field = EMPTY issues.

A workaround is to do (field != value OR field = EMPTY) but I was told that this was not the way it used to be so I was wondering if there is a setting for that.

Thanks!

Robert

 

3 answers

1 accepted

1 vote
Answer accepted

No, it hasn't changed. 

"Does not equal" is not quite the same as "empty" because != says you're looking for a specific value to not be there.  If there's no values to look for, you can't say that your selection isn't there because there's nothing to look for.

Well, not since JIRA 3, which didn't have JQL, so you didn't have != or empty.

Thanks, that was what I thought.  I will tell them to use the workaround I listed above.

It's a little bit confusing for humans, because of our fuzzy thinking.  Even a "yes or no" question really has three "answers" - yes, no, and not answered.

My friend explained it by saying "show me a picture of your black cat", then "show me a picture of all your cats who are not black", then "show me a picture of your dog who is not black".  I don't have a dog, so I have to look for "empty" rather than "not black", because there's no dog there to not be black.  (I love English negatives.  Not)

Like Olena Vasylevska likes this

Dang humans.  Makes perfect sense to me, but my customer is still not happy.  His concern is that in the future he will forget to use the "OR field = EMPTY" and miss records in his reports.   I told him I could change the field to required and create a dummy value (called it "no value") and set that as default.  Then go through with bulk change and find all issues with EMPTY values and change them to "no value", but I really do not like that solution as it adds even more clutter in my instance.   Any thoughts on that solution?

Yeah, I know, we need to think more logically :wink:

I think your cluttered solution is about the only option you have without coding.  Or just beating "empty != != " into him.  The problem is that there are genuine uses for having them work differently!

One would think the != Dog would bring back every value, including a non-value as that is not Dog.  To exclude empty you should have to state != Dog and is not EMPTY.  That's the logical solution to any query!!!

Hi

I'm facing the same issue. I need all results that are not 'Dog' , but i want to include all 'None'/Empty results as well.
Can someone help me with the syntax?

labels != Dog OR labels = None
Doesn't do the trick and adding brackets doesn't help either.

labels != Dog OR labels is EMPTY

is the correct syntax.  There is no "None"

Like # people like this

Thanks for the syntax help everyone! This worked for me:

status not in (Done, Rejected) AND 'Customer(S) Reporting' is EMPTY

Hello Everyone - thanks for the syntax references. This worked for me:

status not in (Done, Rejected) AND 'Customer(S) Reporting' is EMPTY

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
TAGS
Community showcase
Published in Jira Align

Best Practices in Jira Align

Hello Jira Align customers! In order to better serve you on your journey with Jira Align, the Community team has worked with the Jira Align team to curate the content in this collection to better s...

106 views 0 3
Read article

Community Events

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find an event

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Unfortunately there are no Community Events near you at the moment.

Host an event

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local event. Learn more about Community Events

Events near you