Why do you not make the format in which pages are stored configurable?

I only came to know about Confluence after joining my current company. I was impressed at how polished the interface was, and how nicely the editor was implemented. Users that do not want to learn the particular details of wiki markup, don't have to learn it; that was great. You had all kinds of cute integration with Gliffy. When I discovered, however that it is not possible to view the markup representation of a page, I was dumbfounded.

The principle of a wiki is NOT merely being able to easily edit a page; it is also to be able to have control over the source representation which is being created. You apparently use some sort of proprietary XML format; while I understand that there are advantages, XML is overly fraught with noise for humans -- doubtless, this is why even though you could expose your native XML and allow it to be edited directly, you don't.

That is WHY *real* wiki's base their syntax on something resembling plain text; it is markup that is, yes, easy for humans to create, but also, the results of transforming it into a display representation is PREDICTABLE and INSPECTABLE. WYSIWYG was an important principle for a single author to create documents intended to be printed; it does not override all other concerns when it comes to collaborative publishing.

In the current instance at work, you are hiding from me the structure of the documents I am trying to create(!), and making it much harder for others to profitable modify that creation (they can't inspect it, only see the result of rendering). Functonally, this is identical to requiring that:

1. Every user simply use, say Microsoft Word to create documents

2. Upload them to a shared file store.

Better in fact: I can still edit RTF documents in vim, if necessary; I don't even have that option with your product.

So what problem does Atlassian think it's solving for it's customers by taking this approach?

I take that no customer actually demanded that you store their markup in XML; the XML markup solves Atlassian's problems better than it solves the problems of customers.

Why not allow your customers to choose what they want? Obviously (since I've been trolling on your support site) I'm not the only person who feels there is a serious problem with the approach you've taken. Your engineers *could* focus on providing abstraction layers that would allow the CUSTOMER to choose the representation format, xml, wiki, yaml whatever: provide a means of defining the abstraction for serialization.

Fortunately, since there are several free alternatives for wiki stacks, I will be recommending that our group standardize on mediawiki -- not because it's easier to use, but because it has the required features, and it is free from a for-profit business who believes in removing those features because it's inconvenient for THEM, at the expense of their CUSTOMERs.

1 answer

Oh Kerry, you have gone a bit too fast and concluded. There was a time in the the earlier versions on Confluence in which the editor itself gave the choice whether to write in Richtext or using using the wiki markup language.

Now the editor is integlligent enough to understand the markup as you type as explained here http://confluence.atlassian.com/display/DOC/Confluence+4.0+Editor+-+What's+Changed+for+Wiki+Markup+Users

Also the reference for the markup language @ http://confluence.atlassian.com/display/DOC/Confluence+Wiki+Markup

It still allows all the fine controls possible using the markup language, except that the editor is a bit more intelligent. Does that cool you down you a bit?

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
Community showcase
Posted 11 hours ago in Canada

Happy New Year - First AUG of the year - great success

Hi Everyone, Hope everyone had a great holiday season and is ready for an exciting 2019.  We had our first AUG last night featuring Tempo Timesheets.  A great presentation and lots of int...

14 views 0 1
View post

Atlassian User Groups

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find a group

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find my local user group

Unfortunately there are no AUG chapters near you at the moment.

Start an AUG

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local meet up. Learn more about AUGs

Groups near you