Create
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Sign up Log in

Ideas should be grouped in multi-level "Core User Needs"

Alexandre Krammel June 29, 2023

Hi,

A good practice when collecting and organizing Ideas (Features) is to have them grouped in multi-level folders that represent core user needs the underlying feature ideas address.

JPD should have a "multi-level" issue type for core user needs.

Notice in the below example that core user needs may be decomposed in many levels until the idea level, so ideas (leaf level) can bem from level 1 to level "n"

Example of Core User Needs and Feature Ideas:

  • Arrange a Vacation Travel
    • Have an Hotel for the Travel
      • Hotel Search
      • Hotel Booking
      • Hotel Payment
    • Have a Flight for the Travel
      • Flight Search
      • Flight Booking
      • Flight Payment
    • Pay for the Travel
      • Financing
        • Search for Financing Proposals
        • Sign Financing Proposal
      • Payment Checkout
        • Credit Card
        • Cash
        • Account-to-Account

4 comments

Comment

Log in or Sign up to comment
Abby Kiesling June 29, 2023

+1. 

 

This is holding me back so much from building out JPD the way that will integrate with our other projects while showing the accurate roadmap. 

Krishna Vempati
I'm New Here
I'm New Here
Those new to the Atlassian Community have posted less than three times. Give them a warm welcome!
June 29, 2023

100% - waiting for the day hierarchies are supported on JPD.

Like Abby Kiesling likes this
Rohan Swami
Atlassian Team
Atlassian Team members are employees working across the company in a wide variety of roles.
June 29, 2023

Hi @Alexandre Krammel in case you haven't seen it, we have a post on how best to do this with the current capabilities of the product. See the section titled "Can we create different issue types and their relationships? (e.g. parent/child or opportunity/solution)" on this page.

Rest assured this is in our plans for the future.

Like # people like this
Abby Kiesling June 29, 2023

Unfortunately, that's not functional for large teams that need to build hierarchies based on Epic v Story tickets.  Ideas are stories, and we can't very well have HUNDREDS of options in a field for each epic we create.  That's just not feasible.  And furthermore, we can't tie an individual field option to an epic on another project.  

 

Can you please let us know when a true hierarchy will be supported in JPD?  

Rohan Swami
Atlassian Team
Atlassian Team members are employees working across the company in a wide variety of roles.
June 30, 2023

Hi Abby, we announce all new features here in the Community, keep an eye on these pages.

Karen Aiken July 5, 2023

The current solution doesn't work well for our team either - 

  • it mixes metaphors in a single list - can't configure fields separately for "opportunities" and "solutions"
  • requires manual synchronization to keep the opportunities' names in line with the picklist
  • doesn't enable nested opportunities, to refine the overall opportunity into needed specifics (eg, Line of Business, Region, Customer Segment)

Hoping for true hierarchy one way or another - for now - our team could get by with a single level of refinement via subitems on ideas. That wouldn't cover all use cases but it would be a start.

David Nadri July 19, 2023

+1

Agree that some form of multi-level hierarchy within JPD is needed in place of using the current flexible fields/views approach. Glad to see JPD team considering it on their roadmap.

Like Abby Kiesling likes this
TAGS
AUG Leaders

Atlassian Community Events