New "Accepted Answer" icon Edited

Hello!

My concern is the newly introduced appearance of "Accept Answer" -> "Accepted Answer" icons. The overall idea is great - to make the signs bigger and easier to notice. And I think it works as intended.

But am I the only one who is confused by their colors?

I mean this one:

AcceptA.jpg

seems to me more "Accepted" (if you allow me to say so) than this one:

AcceptedA.jpg

As for me, the latter shows some kind of uncertainty.

I think it would be better vice versa. Something like that:

Accept answer2.jpg

... I think you've got the idea.

What do you people think? 

 

8 comments

@Grigory Salnikov [SYSSOFT] I had the same feeling :)

I think so too.  The solid block of green looks like a "hey, this is good", and the outline looks more like a question "is this good?"

This is really tricky stuff.  "Accept" versus "Accepted" and outline vs solid-color.  I suspect the idea was for "Accept Answer" in an outline button was the hint to "click here!" and "Accepted Answer" in a solid block was to indicate "this is the one!"  The words may or may not be an improvement from the circle with the checkmark in it so this is good feedback to the design team.  I personally like the words in the boxes although I wonder how well it works for non-English speakers.

The colouring above works nicely as an indicator for the author of the thread. Their action is to accept an answer.

Davin Studer Community Champion Oct 15, 2018

I agree. Quick mock-up below I think the left side is more visually intuitive than the right side.

Untitled.png

Meg Holbrook Community Champion Oct 15, 2018

Maybe the button for AcceptED Answer just needs to read ACCEPTED? @Kevan Lin

Meg Holbrook Community Champion Oct 15, 2018

t least that will visually distinguish for those of us that have bad vision and/or issues reading within different color schemes. 

Thomas Schlegel Community Champion Oct 11, 2018

If there are more than one answers, it might be a problem to see at first glance, which Accept-Button you should click. The one above or the one directly underneath the question. 

image.png

Also true - because of the current fashion to try to avoid delineation with lines, it's not too clear that the accept applies to the answer below, unless it's the first answer.

In some ways, the tick to the left was better in that sense - it clearly belonged to the answer on the same line, although people definitely missed it all the time.

Good observation.

Moreover, today I had a situation when these icons partially screened messages behind them.

Kevan Lin Atlassian Team Oct 11, 2018

What do you mean by "icons partially screened messages behind them"? The icons didn't show up?

No, icons shielded the text and it was partially unreadable.

Should I encounter this behaviour again, I'll post a screenshot.

Kevan Lin Atlassian Team Oct 11, 2018

Yes please take a screenshot next time. I'd be interested to see if I can replicate it.

Hi, @Kevan Lin!

It's me again.

I did some research and, as promised, am back with the results.

Today I've encountered something like this (though the icons 'shielded' even more text):

1.jpg

2.jpg

Here's the example page:

How do I pre-populate text to a description field on JIRA Cloud version 7.x?

I've also noticed this:

3.jpg

It happens all the time when the page is not fully loaded and lasts a couple of seconds.

A small thing but still an eye-catcher.

As an addition, I also attach examples from the mobile view (page is the same as above):

IMG_20181011_231102.pngIMG_20181011_231123.png

Kevan Lin Atlassian Team Oct 11, 2018

Ohhh I see. Yes we are aware of that bug. It's essentially a padding/margin error.

cc:@Matt Jared 

Kevan Lin Atlassian Team Oct 11, 2018

Thanks everyone for your feedback! We've known about the issue behind accepting an answer for quite some time and are trying to improve this experience. Obviously with every change there could also be something better, all of these comments are helping in making this experience even better - so keep them coming!

@Grigory Salnikov [SYSSOFT] great discussion, thank you for starting it!

You could always move it into the Feedback Forum for the rest of the community to weigh in as well, but I'll leave it here in case you wanted to keep it to Champions only. 

@Monique van den Berg, you are welcome! Glad to help :)

Yes, I'll certainly move it into the Feedback forum, where it belongs.

At first, I was unsure where to publish it.

Dang - now I know there is a secret squirrel area I cannot see.

@Kat Warner you never know, you may get into the secret squirrel area one of these days. 😉

Jack Brickey Community Champion Oct 17, 2018

FWIW, here is my $0.02.

I would like to see a cleaner look w/ fewer words. I liked the simply check mark TBH but clearly it was not obvious enough. So how about this...

 

accept.jpg

If we thing that including "Answer" as part of this then I would vote for only doing so on the "Accept" button. There is not value adding to "Accepted".

Another update that may be helpful.

Today I've received a notification that my answer has been accepted:

IMG_20181019_091616.png

I don't know what exactly happened, but when I logged in to check and reply my answer was no longer accepted:

IMG_20181019_091438.png

I tend to think that the end-user may have been confused by the outline icon and changed it back to solid green, which seems 'more accepted'.

There should be logs somewhere.

We discussed exactly this yesterday in the Community Board, and the champions pretty much all agreed that the outline/solid should be reversed so the solid green shows "accepted". 

The leads have several things they're looking at changing around the "accept" process, and this is one of them.

For what it's worth, the acceptance rate jumped by 7% when the bigger green boxes appeared.

Just a small follow-up from my experience:

usercase.jpg

Comment

Log in or Sign up to comment
Community showcase
Published Feb 06, 2019 in Feedback & Announcements

Community release notes for February 6, 2019

It's time for another installment of community release notes! We've got new goodies from our developers, our designers, our community team, and even our product teams this time around! 🎉 New:...

340 views 8 19
Read article

Atlassian User Groups

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find a group

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find my local user group

Unfortunately there are no AUG chapters near you at the moment.

Start an AUG

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local meet up. Learn more about AUGs

Groups near you