Is there added value from Git Integration Plugin for Jira if one already has Fisheye and Crucible?

[Pavel Boev]

Hello,

We are migrating projects from one Jira instance, which has the Git Integration Plugin https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/com.xiplink.jira.git.jira_git_plugin/server/overview to another Jira instance, which does not have the plugin, but is integrated with Fisheye / Crucible.

I wonder if it is worth the money to buy the Git Integration Plugin and install it on the system, which already has Fisheye / Crucible.

It seems to me that this plugin has a lot of overlapping functionality with Fisheye / Crucible.

The receiving Jira is at 2000-users tier and that plugin will cost almost 3000$.

It's not a big sum, but we're already paying 16000$ for Crucible / Fisheye, so I was wondering if this plugin will be worth the extra 3 grands.

Thanks in advance for your suggestions