We're looking to migrate from SVN/Jenkins/Mantis to Stash/Bamboo/JIRA. We typically have 3-5 Java webapps in a project built using Maven, along with one or two .NET Windows apps also built with Maven, and the whole set is released together in a unified deployment.
Should we create a single Stash project with a single Git repo for each project, and a single Bamboo plan to build it all?
Or multiple repositories under a Stash project, one repo per webapp?
The automatic branching features in Stash, Bamboo and JIRA seem to be optimized for a single repo being the common case.
I would say it boils down to answer to 2 simple questions: are webapps from single project often changed together? If you go with single repo per project would the size of it become a problem?
If the answer to first is 'yes' and second 'no' then I would go with single repository.
As you said, branching in Bamboo is optimized for single repository case. I also find it personally much more convienient if I don't have to look for components of single project in 5 different places ;-) But YMMV.
Just to add to Marcin's comment.
This is an area that IMHO still has some room for improvement (you might be interested in this recent blog from a colleague of mine).
Marcin is right - generally tooling, including Stash/Maven/Bamboo/Everything work better with a single repository. The longer you can stick with that the most comfortable off you'll be. There are two places where this becomes a real problem (which is what Marcin is really talking about with 'size' above)
1. You need to 'share' a single repository/library/module/product with more than one repository. At this point you need to use Maven/Git-Submodule/Git-Subtree to 'depend' on the other repository.
2. Build speed - the maven build of a single repository becomes unwieldy/horrible and you want to improve performance.
Again, if you don't have either of those problems then having a single repository is almost always the easiest.
PS. FWIW I think this is solvable, but we need to ditch Maven first. :)
Thanks for signing up for Jira Ops! I’m Matt Ryall, leader for the Jira Ops product team at Atlassian. Since this is a brand new product, we’ll be delivering improvements quickly and sharing updates...
Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!Find a group
Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!
Unfortunately there are no AUG chapters near you at the moment.Start an AUG
You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local meet up. Learn more about AUGs