Come for the products,
stay for the community

The Atlassian Community can help you and your team get more value out of Atlassian products and practices.

Atlassian Community about banner
4,365,212
Community Members
 
Community Events
168
Community Groups

Is there a way to build C++ Application under multiple platforms (Windows/Linux) without the Remote Agent?

Norbert Rising Star Apr 01, 2012

Hi

We use Bamboo too build our C++ Application under Windows
so far so good, but now we want also we need it to be build under Linux (Multiplattform support)

Is there a way to do this without an Remote Agent because I don't wont to spend 800 € only for Linux/Unix support.
I know we probably can crosscompile but this is also not such a good solution .

3 answers

1 accepted

1 vote
Answer accepted

Do an ssh in your job to your linux box (enable password less ssh so that no questions are asked) and execute the make command. Do an scp to get back the resultant binaries so that bamboo can artifact the results.

As Renjith pointed out, there are certainly workarounds to utilise local agents to test on multiple platforms. However, you might want to consider the overhead of setting up and maintaining this configuration vs the cost of spending $800 in the first year and $400 for renewals. I am frequently surprised how undervalued developer time is when it comes to maintaining build environments.

Norbert Rising Star Apr 02, 2012

Thanks but its hard for me to justify 800 $ for not a "must" feature.
Especially if we don't have a paying unix customer.. :-(

PiotrA Rising Star Apr 02, 2012

Just curious - are you using starter (10$) license?

edit: I've allowed myself to improve your question title so future users can find this question more easily (if they are interested in running multiplaform test without the Remote Agents). I assume it's OK, right? :)

Norbert Rising Star Apr 02, 2012

Yes Starter license..

And yes its ok

PiotrA Rising Star Apr 02, 2012

Hm, that makes sense - I can see a reason not to go with 790$ expenses just to support another platform, especially if one is developing small application(s) with a low revenue (like some startup for example). Things go worse if one would like to support yet another platform (MacOS?) - then the additional Bamboo cost goes up to 2190$.

@Jens, what's the goal of Bamboo Starter licenses? I think they totally miss the point when considering multiplatform building (C/C++ area, for example small video games shops, etc). Care to follow this up in private mail conversation?

@Norbert, I would love to hear more about your use-case for Bamboo. Let me know if you are happy to chat about it.

Norbert Rising Star Apr 02, 2012

@Jens
fell free to contact me, you should have my emailadresse..

This is a very old post and yet, the licence model still seems to be really harsh for multi-platform C++ projects. Did anything at all come out of your chat with Jens, Norbert?

Norbert Rising Star Jul 10, 2018

@Christian
Jens never contacted me
since the demand of our UNIX solution increased we spend the money on a Bamboo license..
In my opinion its still quite overpriced (especially compared to other available tools)
but changing to another platform would be more of a hassle then just paying the 400$ per year

We currently have an intern redoing our build scripts because of technical debt. So the licensing costs doesn't matter compared to the cost of the developer.

Thanks for the reply. Too bad Jens never got back to you :/ It might be off topic and an unwelcome subject here but which tool would you use if you could start over and weren't locked into Bamboo? We just started looking into possible CI solutions and from what I've seen so far, platform independent ones are few and far between, so Bamboo still seems appealing despite it not having been designed with C++ in mind.

Norbert Rising Star Jul 10, 2018

in my old company we use MS TeamSystem Buildservice  which is quite good for C++ but  only usable for Windows

Currently other groups in our company use Jenkins
no experience about it myself but as far as I understood quite promising

 

regarding the buildscriptswe are planning to move to cmake, but it's a long term project and currently no urgency to do this (also a job for an intern)

1 vote
PiotrA Rising Star Apr 01, 2012

I don't think there is a feasible way to CI multiplatform project using Bamboo without the Remote Agent(s). :(

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
TAGS

Atlassian Community Events