It's not the same without you

Join the community to find out what other Atlassian users are discussing, debating and creating.

Atlassian Community Hero Image Collage

How do I properly handle secrets with Bamboo 6.2 onwards

In Bamboo versions which support Specs, how do I correctly handle secrets in my build plans? Storing them in plain text in the repository seems like bad practice.

2 answers

3 votes

Good question, the bootstrapping of secrets is a complex problem for configuration in code in general.

I'm not aware of a dedicated recommendation from the Bamboo team and would appreciate if they'd chime in as well, but here are two approaches that I'd consider at this point:

1. In line with the Twelve-Factor App's Config advise, configuration that varies should be stored in the environment. Accordingly, for contexts that allow the use of Bamboo variables (like tasks), you could store the secrets in an automatically encrypted 'password variable' - this behavior is not properly documented, but referenced from Defining global variables:

Note that if your new global variable contains the word 'password' then the value field will be automatically encrypted. If you change a variable to include the word 'password', then the value field will change from viewable text to an asterisk string.

You can then reference those Variables from Bamboo Specs.

  • Using secured Environment variables is also the pattern recommended by the Bitbucket Pipelines team btw.

2. As a variation of the aforementioned pattern, you could also retrieve the secrets at runtime from an external service and then inject them into variables via a task, for example the built-in Bamboo Variables task.

Of course, this requires that your access to said service is in itself properly secured, which would apply for scenarios that can leverage securely stored credentials, for example Bamboos built-in Shared credentials, or third party apps like Identity Federation for AWS (Bamboo) (Disclaimer: I'm the co-founder of this app's vendor Utoolity).

Steffen, I appreciate your well thought out answer, especially since I posted this only a few hours ago.

I feel this question is best asked to the Bamboo team in a broad scope (I'd love some guidelines/best practices around specs!) but specially, I'm asking this question as a DevOps engineer trying to implement a Configuration as code solution using Bamboo Specs. 

In my specific case, I've used Bamboo variables within tasks, however I'm concerned that their encrypted form in Specs is usable cross plans. I found that Password/secret variables which are defined in the scope of one project result in the same encrypted values as the same Password/secret variable defined in another, suggesting you could copy encrypted values between projects, decrypt them, and expose the secrets.

I'm leaning towards your second suggestion, though I think setting up shared credentials requires admin on a project?

it seems strange to have rely on an external services here and I hope the Bamboo team can shed some light.

Also worth mentioning is the topic of restricting access to utilize the secrect in a task or similar. Be aware that some of the suggested solutions are "global" in nature, meaning that the secret can be utilized by anyone in Bamboo (anyone who can edit a plan).

Let's say you have secrets in Bamboo which are meant for deployment, not for build. However, you may have a fair amount of users which you allow to do build plans. In this case, I don't see how you can prevent a user who's meant only to be able to do build steps to actually take advantage of such secret, even though this shouldn't happen.

Bottom line:  Bamboo's build-in features for managing secrets take some steps to make it hard to utilize the secret outside of Bamboo, but doesn't help you in respect to who has access to make use of the secret inside Bamboo, i.e. in plans. 

* About solution one, to set Global variables will be not allowed in our company.  Second, it will be not easy way to manage, because we have about 3~5 different secrets variables for each build plan and we have hundreds and thousand plans

In previous way with normal bamboo plan, we manually create secret variables (PASSWORD_XXXX) for each bamboo plan.

 

* About solution two, it is not for secrets. because we don't want to save the key (whatever it is encrypted or not) in source codes. 

 

So seems this feature (bamboo yaml spec)  is still not ready for use. 

 

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
Community showcase
Published in Bamboo

Unable to add or edit Bitbucket Cloud repository in Bamboo

On 31 May, a GDPR-related change went live in the Bitbucket Cloud API that resulted in users not being able to create or edit Bitbucket Cloud Linked repositories in Bamboo. This API update removed t...

1,142 views 2 7
Read article

Community Events

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find an event

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Unfortunately there are no Community Events near you at the moment.

Host an event

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local event. Learn more about Community Events

Events near you