Just started using the new Jira automation in Jira Software Cloud. I created a very simple automation to email the reporter whenever an issue is created - just for test purposes. When I create a "To Do" issue it fires as expected and sends the email. However if I create any other type of issue (Defect, Requirement, other custom issue types that we have) the automation is not triggered and I get no email. What am I missing?
Here is the automation. There is no clause that checks for the type of issue:
It is scoped to a single project and it is enabled:

When I create a new "To Do" issue in that project, the automation fires and I get an email. When I create any other kind of issue in that project, no run of the automation and no email.