I am looking to have SSO integration with Re:solution plugin in Confluence. SAML Single Sign.
I would like to know what are the Pros and con's using Okta or Azure AD or ADFS.
if anyone has already done comparison or why you chose Okta or Azure AD, it would be helpful for me.
In terms of integration, the identity provider should work with the connector the same for any of the products you mentioned. On the backend, they all use SAML assertions to pass information to the re:solution plugin.
Firstly, I would consider ADFS if you're already working in an on-premise Active Directory environment. The ADFS setup can use your existing Domain Controller infrastructure to just run the ADFS / ADFS proxy model without too much fuss. You can of course add more servers dedicated to just ADFS, but it's entirely possible to just run the services on your existing servers. If your Confluence server and other services you want to connect with SSO are already behind a firewall and not accessible over the internet, ADFS probably makes the most sense.
If on the other hand, you have Cloud services that would benefit from SAML as well, then Okta and Azure AD are likely to be easier to set up. Here are some pro's that come to mind for each option:
I found this discussion weighing the pros and cons between Okta and Azure AD as well that might be interesting to have a read through. In terms of integration with Atlassian apps / SAML for Confluence Server though, they're all pretty much equal. It's on the administration / cost side that you'll want to consider the differences between the offerings.
Hey y’all! Grab a cup of ☕ and check out the latest installment of Cloud Cafe – our video series about cloud app development on Atlassian. If you’re new to Cloud Cafe, check out the first few episo...
Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!Find an event
Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!
Unfortunately there are no Community Events near you at the moment.Host an event
You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local event. Learn more about Community Events