Gerrit code scoring in Bitbucket - any add-ons out there?

[Alex Christensen]

Our development teams used to use Gerrit before we transitioned over to Bitbucket. There are some features in Gerrit that several of our teams miss, such as the code scoring methods Gerrit has (-2, -1, 0, +1, +2).

Are there any options I have to implement something similar to extend Bitbucket's code review or pull request functionality? My searches and research have pretty much reached a dead end, so I was hoping the Community might be able to help provide insight or point me in a direction I haven't gone down yet.

[Julius Davies _bit-booster_com_]

We maintain two add-ons (one free, one paid) that work together to provide a gerrit-like experience on Bitbucket:

1.  Control Freak for Bitbucket Server (free) blocks merges based on approval and rejection thresholds (e.g., the +2 and -2 mechanism of Gerrit):

2.  PR-Booster for Bitbucket Server (paid) makes sure approvals are dropped and rejections remain in place when new commits are received:

The end-result maps to Gerrit's review scoring like so:

- Users with write access to the repo can Approve (+2) or Reject (-2).

- Votes from users with read-only access can be configured to only count as "Light Approve (+1)" and "Light Reject (-1)".

- If users with write access want to make +1 or -1 votes, they can do that by leaving comments in the PR activity stream (e.g., "This is looking good, but I'm not confident about approving it for merge.").

[Aron Gombas _Midori_]

I'd check this app: https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1211303/workzone-pullrequest-workflow?hosting=server&tab=overview

To me it seems you can write little formulas and it works with approval quotas, etc. It may meet or at least approximate your preferred way.