I am working on setting up some automations with workflows one in particular I am having trouble with is - After I close a task, whether I set it to "done", "canceled", "resolved" etc, and the customer sends back an email stating that the task is in fact not done, I would like that task to move to the "Reopened" column in my board view. I want to be able to see when a customer emails back stating that the task is not complete. I have tried using the prebuilt automation rule below -

I thought this would be easy by creating a new column with the "reopened" status is my Kanban board view

I get emails that say automation has failed, but nothing further.