Tickets created on the top of the page with "Create" button do not show up on our board.

However, if we create an issue in the Column of the board itself it shows 
I can't seem to locate why this is happening, the tickets exist, if we enter the ticket number in the URL they show up, but they are not viewable in the board in any way. We've assigned them, given them labels, but they're not displaying.
What could be causing this?