Tanguy Crusson Atlassian Team

@Alex Kessler based on your screenshot I think I know what happened: * You have Jira Software in your company's Jira (xyz.atlassian.net) * Then you've added Jira Product Discovery to another site (xyz2.atlassian.net) - maybe when trying the product, because you don't have admin rights to your company's Jira? (that's the…

Hi @Aaron Mosny yes, but it's subtle today (we plan to improve that): you see the idea in the list of linked issues in the Jira Software ticket.

@Jan-Hendrik Spieth thanks. What you can do is create a formula field / "write your own". Then create another one (formula / "weighted score") that has the first one as an input. That will give you a normalized value. 

Hi @Jan-Hendrik Spieth , it's a problem in the documentation - the roll up just adds the values. If you want normalization, you can use a "weighted score" formula

Hi @__ Jimi Wikman , that's correct, you can't change it currently.

Hi everyone, so the short answer is we have a bug on how we account for ideas that don't have a value for a field in the weighted score formula. We'll fix it!

You're right @Jan-Hendrik Spieth there is something fishy here: https://www.loom.com/share/4c75e73760d142c2a047bc3ef0331cf1 

Thanks @Sam Sherar , that makes complete sense! Always happy to chat to better understand how teams use the product and how we can make it better: https://calendly.com/tcrusson/30min-1

That's great feedback @Sam Sherar , in fact we were wondering if we should make the impact score more contextual - not a 0-100 score for the entire list of ideas, but a 0-100 score for the ideas in the view (not filtered out). The only way I can see around your problem today is to find a way to make the score zero for the…

Hi @Tim Cromwell , Generally we've seen teams using the flexible fields and views to do that - a bit like how you would do it in spreadsheets. Here's what we have in the FAQ: Can we create different issue types and their relationships? (e.g. parent/child or opportunity/solution) Not yet, but it's on the roadmap. In the…

OK thanks @Ally Akbarzadeh , so basically: aesthetics and information density. Got it!

OK damn - would you be ok to jump on a Zoom early next week? https://calendly.com/tcrusson/15min-meeting So we can troubleshoot this together

Thanks for the feedback @Ally Akbarzadeh . Just so we're clear with what you need, what are the aspects in what you shared that help you tell a better story? Thanks!

OK - we'll need to look into it, it could very well be a bug. In the meantime, have you tried creating a new "Score" field with the same configuration?

Hi @[deleted] - good idea, we'll look into it

Hi @Cassidy Fitzpatrick , could this be because of the "Votes" field? It's not on the screenshot you shared

Noted re: cross-project views - we have it on the roadmap for later. On the delivery dates front: let me turn the question back to you 😉 How would you expect that to work based on your context? What do you link to ideas in the delivery panel, and how would you expect that to inform the progress/timeframe of what's on the…

Thanks for the feedback @Jan-Hendrik Spieth. You could create different date fields for start/end dates, that back different timeline views for the same feature but different products. e.g. 4 date fields that you'd use in 2 different views: * View 1: "Roadmap for Product X"* Start date field: "Start (Product X)" * End date…

@Matt Lane @Will Le it's something we have on the roadmap for later. There will be some implications to be able to do that: * First we need to make sure that fields can be shared across projects * Then we need to do some work so we can pull data from multiple projects * And then you'll be able to create views that show…

Hi @mchr and @Will Le , we are currently working on that - the ability to share views with people who may not have a Jira account. They'll need to have an Atlassian account, which they can get for free at https://id.atlassian.com/signup In the meantime the workaround that @Will Le describes will work well during beta.

That's a pretty neat idea, thanks for sharing @Jan-Hendrik Spieth !

@Jeremy West sorry I accidentally deleted part of the response - I edited it back :) Yes, it's pretty much the same concept as Jira Service Management 👍 Not the exact same admin functions but close enough - we're still working through the details here, we'll share something in a bit.

Hi @Jeremy West , we've found a solution so you can share views with anyone who has an Atlassian account (free to create on https://id.atlassian.com/signup) but we're not going to be able to support fully anonymous access (public link on the internet, for people without an account at all). We just finished the technical…

Thanks for the very clear feedback @Jan-Hendrik Spieth. This piece of feedback has come up numerous times in the past couple of weeks actually - we're looking at how we can best approach it. Initially it was mostly product managers spending time in Jira Product Discovery (and this spreadsheet-like behaviour was not perfect…

Hi @David Nadri I'm planning to share an update pretty soon with the latest, but basically we're about to start dogfooding this in the next week or so - if all goes well we'll start to give access to early beta testers shortly after that. 

@David Nadri yep there is an API to create an idea, it's just the Jira Cloud REST API for creating issues - which lets you specify the issue type (idea) and set field values. You can add insights to ideas using the Jira Product Discovery specific API.

Cool, thanks for the context @J P - it sounds like what we have planned would help you there

If you don't mind sharing: what are the fields you want to make compulsory?

It's not something that comes up frequently as feedback @serhat so not high priority today. Usually the teams we talked to looked for a more flexible/less structured way to capture information quickly as ideas - and refine them later if/when they decide to explore them in more details. We definitely do plan to integrate…

Hi @serhat , it's not something that the product supports today. There's 2 related features though: * if you create a view with a filter (e.g. "product = A and team = X"), and you create an idea from that view - then these field values will be automatically applied. * you can create templates for an idea's description - to…