Multiple users for my company account-unique problem not resolved by anyone

Question

RE: Account verification issues with company accounts

Good Morning all at Trello, first of all I love your product.  It is amazing, but before I put my life into this product, I need to make sure that I am setup as a company account.

Here is why

Rationale: Every system seems to be using something called id.me, persona, and the like to verify accounts.  But, none of these systems were smart enough to put in metrics for company/organizational accounts. Small non-profits like mine typically have one login for several volunteers.  And it was going well until this awful bug called id.me and persona.

Oh my I cannot believe that I am the only company that has run into this issue.  Typically companies are able to setup more than one account id under the same company.  I want to make sure that your company is equipped to do that.

For I do not want to have one of my authorized volunteers login to your systems and then be prompted to identify herself.  For it is a company account.  Sorry to have to bring this difficult question, but I just happen to be highly intelligent and my question has not been answered by anyone yet.

Please, advise when you are able

In Christ Holy Service

Lt. Helen

Founder/Owner/CEO

NegroWomenWarriors

Ed Letifov _TechTime - New Zealand_ · Answer

Hello @Lt_ Helen

What you are doing EXPLICITLY violates Atlassian Customer Agreement clause 3 (sharing accounts between multiple people), why are you surprised that nobody there is willing to help you?

If you are a volunteer organisation — this won't help you with Trello, but given that a lot of Trello functionality can be done with Jira, maybe you should look at this: https://www.atlassian.com/teams/nonprofits/discount-pricing

Oleksandr · Answer

Lt. Helen,

Trello can support an organization setup, but not by having several volunteers share one Trello/Atlassian login.

The usual setup is:

Create a Trello Workspace for the organization.

Each volunteer creates their own Atlassian/Trello account.

Invite those accounts to the Workspace or to specific boards.

For stronger company-level control, use an Atlassian Organization with domain verification / managed accounts.

Official docs:

https://support.atlassian.com/trello/docs/inviting-people-to-a-workspace/https://support.atlassian.com/trello/docs/how-to-manage-trello-in-your-organization/https://support.atlassian.com/user-management/docs/verify-a-domain-to-manage-accounts/https://support.atlassian.com/trello/docs/managed-atlassian-accounts-for-trello/

So the answer is: yes, Trello can be used as an organizational account structure, but the safer and supported model is one organization Workspace with separate user accounts, not one shared login. On Standard/Premium, adding Workspace members can affect billing, so check the member count and plan details before inviting everyone.

From the thread, it looks like the main concern is avoiding identity-verification problems when different volunteers use the same login. Separate user accounts should avoid most of that issue because each person signs in as themselves.

Lt. Helen · Answer

Sir, I have a brand new paid subscription, that I am testing. (I always pay I want nothing for free!) So, I have other companies that I have moved/moving from because they have not been able to answer the question.  I have run into problems at the other companies that have not been able to resolve the issue. I do not want to run into the problem again, so here at Trello, I am being proactive. I want to know ahead of time if they can handle a true organizational account.

My father told me I was smart, but my goodness.  So, I tested a lot of companies, linkedin.com, persona, id.me and the like none of them have no idea what I am talking about.  Oh my.

I could write  the algorithm in my sleep.  All you need is company portal for the companies, AKA screen door, than create allow user logins to open the main door.  I mean really!!! They want individual accounts for 36 billion people, just because we have the technology that can sustain it.  What if they work for more than one company, have multiple email address, work cell phone, multiple work locations and the like. They never ever considered it!

This is outrageous, and we are suppose to trust this incompetence with our personal data.  And let wreckless AI run the planet. lol.. oh my.

I will keep looking until I find a solution. If I do find intelligent life somewhere I will post here.

In Christ Holy Service

Lt Helen

Founder/Owner/CEO

NegroWomenWarriors

REALINTELLIGENCE