For example, I make a new web link and put the address as:
http://www.google.com/?truth=me%3Dcool
And the link text as:
test
When I save the page, the address turns into:
http://www.google.com/?truth=me%253Dcool
The link text stays the same:
This is not acceptable, it ruins the intentional %'s I have in my url.
% is not a character you can use in urls without encoding.
Have another look at your first url, it actually says ?truth=me=cool, because the % in it indicates that there's an encoded character next, and %3D is "="
Confluence is doing the encoding correctly for you, turning your % into %25
Hi Kelv,
If you want to use a specific link and you don't want Confluence to change it in any way, you need to embed it in an HTML macro.
I have just experienced the same behavior, when pasting the URL of a JIRA JQL search into a Web Link.
The JIRA Filter Macro is not always desirable, as it will show the filter results, or just print the number of results.
Sometimes, we just want a named hyperlink to some JQL search in Jira. This is only possilbe using the Web Link.
So when pasting the URL of the JIRA JQL search, and then saving the link, all % chars are encoded to %25. So what was "%3D", becomes, "%253D".
.... now for the ridiculous part....
Edit the Web Link, and then save it again, without changing anything.
It keep appending %25 to the URL.
So what was "%253D", becomes "%25253D", "%2525253D", "%2525253D", "%2325253D".... for every save.
Really???
It could be that "Confluence is doing the encoding correctly for you, turning your % into %25" but it is not meeting the user need, and it breaks everything.
The Web Link is blind to this use case.
This is a clear Bug in usability!
No, you're wrong. And right.
You are wrong because "Confluence is doing the encoding correctly for you, turning your % into %25" is correct. It has to, or you get garbage.
You are right when you say "Confluence is doing the encoding correctly for you, turning your % into %25 repeatedly". That is absolutely a bug.
Correct. However, from the usabilty perspective, this is not working. It could be technically correct, but it renders this feature useless.
The JIRA Filter Macro will clean the URL for you, and then show you the JQL.
So, the Web Link dialog could do the same, i.e., decode on paste, then encode on save.
The usability on the encoding is irrelevant - it doesn't work without encoding, so you need it. But yes, it's broken when it repeatedly does it.
It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
