Trello keeps asking me to link my Evernote account when trying to Create or Attach a note.

Which I do:

But afterward when I go to Attach or Create a note through a Trello card, it still asks me to link my Evernote account.
I've tried restarting Trello, disabling/enabling the power-up, and deauthorizing/reauthorizing Evernote, but the issue persists.
Any ideas?