can we manage Stash review comments in Crucible?

mohit mathur

We have been using Stash for code reviews during code merge. Recently we have also started using Crucible for adhoc code reviews. We have decided to continue with Stash as it supports pull requests base code merge which helps us to manage and merge only reviewed code. At the same time considering the versatility and flexibility of Crucible, we would like to use Crucible as code review management tool. Hence, we would like to import and/or manage stash review comments in Crucible. Could you please get back to us if we can manage Stash review comments in Crucible?

Please help us.
Thanks

gustavo_refosco

Hi Mohit,

This is not possible. In fact comments in Crucible and Stash are handled very differently, each being part of its own application - besides the fact that a Crucible review is different of a Stash pull request.

Though I think this would be a very nice feature I believe it would involve very big changes in design, therefore I'm not sure if this would have a chance to be developed but please, if you like, you may create a feature request for this, specifying it further, at https://jira.atlassian.com. You may refer to Atlassian's policy for the implementation of new features.

Regards,

Gustavo Refosco