Hello, I'm trying to set up Jenkins integration on a server of ours, but I'm seeing odd behavior in the logs and not seeing any alerts or notifications out of OpsGenie.

As far as I can tell, the Jenkins integration is telling OpsGenie to close an alert without ever actually creating it. All alert policies have been suspended, so nothing should be auto deleting or closing them.
Reading through the docs on the integration and the Jenkins plugin, there doesn't seem to be a way to control what action should be taken on an alert. On the Jenkins side I'm trying this in both pipeline and freestyle jobs, same behavior on both.
The only other issue similar to this one I found was https://community.atlassian.com/t5/Opsgenie-questions/Opsgenie-delayed-incomingData/qaq-p/1648853 but it appears unrelated.
I figured I would ask the community about this before opening a ticket. Has anyone seen similar behavior before?