Create
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Sign up Log in

Testing Portfolio on both Cloud and Server and having two very different experiences

Stephanie Willis April 1, 2019

I'm trying to determine if we have a version or user problem or if the functionality between Portfolio for Cloud and Server are very different. 

I like the features I'm seeing in Portfolio for Server and I can't figure out how to replicate these on Cloud. Is it possible? Some of them are:

  1. The concept of a Program -- being able to have multiple plans roll up into a program and display the initiative level roadmap items on a single roadmap. 
  2. The "Roadmap" view of a Plan. On Server, I have three options: Roadmap, Teams, Releases. On Cloud I have: Scope, Team, Releases. Scope is similar, but the roadmap is created above the items that feed into it instead of aside them. The roadmap on cloud seems to be completely algorithm based while server seems to give the user some control.
  3. Review changes - in server, when I make changes that will impact JIRA, I see a "Review changes" button with a number of how many changes I made. I can accept or decline these before pushing the changes to JIRA.

 

Overall, the two seem to behave very differently for me and I can't figure out if the versions between both are just different or if it's an install problem.

1 answer

1 accepted

3 votes
Answer accepted
samrobertsofficial
Atlassian Team
Atlassian Team members are employees working across the company in a wide variety of roles.
April 3, 2019

Hey @Stephanie Willis ,

There are some changes between the Cloud and Server versions of Portfolio for Jira. This can happen as certain features are prioritised differently for different deployment options. For more on this see https://community.atlassian.com/t5/Portfolio-for-Jira-articles/Introducing-a-new-planning-experience-in-Portfolio-for-Jira/bc-p/977363#M44

To go though your cases:

  1. Programs is only available in the Server version.
  2. It looks like you have the 'new experience' feature enabled on your Server plan. Those differences you mentioned are correct. 
  3. In Cloud this can be found under the "Uncommitted changes" button.

Are you looking to use Cloud or Server going forward into the future? 

Thanks,

Sam

Stephanie Willis April 4, 2019

Thanks Sam! I don't want the roadmap to be based on an algorithm, I want something very low effort for the PMs on my team to make changes to. We are on Cloud right now but considering switching to Server for this feature.

Like Rajesh Viswanathan likes this
Lisa Giannini April 9, 2019

Is there any update on a target release date for Portfolio 3.0 Cloud?  We are on Cloud and plan to remain there.

Like Rajesh Viswanathan likes this
Marianne Lee _Nagarro_ February 10, 2020

Hi,

Are there any articles available for feature comparison between Portfolio server and cloud today?  I can't seem to find any and this is needed to manage the transition during our migration of Jira server to Jira Cloud.  Our users have raised questions during testing on the differences they encountered, and couldn't find the equivalent of the functions they have been used to in Portfolio 3 on Jira server.

E.g. lack of programs in Portfolio Cloud, planning interface looks different, no drag-and-drop interactivity in the timeline/schedule/roadmap, bulk actions not available in Cloud to update issues, filter options not available, etc.

For functionalities or features not available in Portfolio Cloud, are there workarounds available? Users have been used to these features in Portfolio 3, and this seems to be a downgrade for them when we migrate Jira to cloud.

 

Regards,

Marianne

Like Rajesh Viswanathan likes this

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
TAGS
AUG Leaders

Atlassian Community Events