Zephyr for JIRA 2.5 can't delete test step

After upgrading to the latest Z4J version (2.5) We are no longer able to delete test steps. We have tried reindexing both JIRA and Zephyr with no luck? Is anyone else having this issue?

15 answers

1 accepted

Hi Chris,

In Zephyr for JIRA 2.5, Zephyr for JIRA changed permissions on how people can delete Steps in test issues. See attached screenshot on what the error looks like.

This permission is now controlled by the Project Permission -> Delete Issue. If the user is part of the group that has this permission, they can delete steps in addition to other items. If their group is not part of this project permission, they will get the error mentioned above. Administrators are usually the only groups in this permission set by default.

Regards,

Daniel

If you want to give separate permissions for deleting steps that is fine, but don't link it with deleting issues. Now we have to give permissions to all users who use zypher to be able to delete issues... bad move

This solved our problem as well.Thank you for your help!

However i want to agree with Oscar and state that linking this to the delete issue permission is bad practice.

Thanks for the response and resolution on this.

I'll ditto the two previous comments. Individual test step delete permissions are one thing, but extending rights to include overall 'issue' deletion = not a good idea.

I agree. I can't give my QA people admin permissions (delete issue) just so that they can delete test steps.

I also agree, this is a terrible way to handle permissions. We can't give our QA team permission to delete issues just so they can manage their test steps.

Please, please find a way to use a separate permission value so we can let our QA engineers delete test steps without having to give them permission to delete actual Jira issues.

Hello Chris,

We need some additional information to resolve this issue.Could you please provide the below information:
1)Which database you are using?
2)Which JIRA version you are using?
3)Could you please record the whole session so that we can be on the same page regarding the issue you are facing.

You can use Webex player for the same.
http://www.webex.com/play-webex-recording.html

Thank you,

Kind regards,

Zephyr Support

1) SQL Server 2012

2) 6.1.5

3) I'll see if I can have one of my team record that this morning.

Thanks!

We're also affected by the new behavior and completely agree with previous posts: Requiring "Delete Issue" permission to merely delete a test step is an unwanted side effect of the upgrade to 2.5.

Sadly, we are considering downgrading.

Same here, we'll be downgrading. I do not want to give global "delete issue" permissions to my testers!

Please add us as another organisation that is affected and frustrated at this change.

It is absolutely ridiculous to expect organisations to give non admin users permission to delete Issues just so they can delete a Test Step.

I sincerely hope you reconsider this change, or at least provide the option of disabling the check. I, or any of our admins, do not have the time run around after my Test Analysts deleting Test Steps for them as there is no way I will be able to get permission to allow them to have "Delete Issue" permissions.

Regards,

Phil Baird

A non-privileged user (lacking 'Delete Issue' rights) can edit/empty all of a step's fields. This leaves ugly clutter but provides a workaround of sorts.

... Adding to your workaround insight...

We also initially realized the ability to still edit/empty step fields.

My instruction to testers was to drag those empty test steps to the top/bottom of the script (execution string)... so at least they were all compiled in one spot for deletion.

This will cut down on the inline script clutter you mentioned.

Nice point, G3, and worth sharing with the team.

On another note, Zephyr has expressed a willingness to release a patch. They asked if delete test step should be handled by a user- or group-based right. My response was to tie this back to "Edit Issue" permission.

May I ask if others might post their ideas here?

I agree with tieing it back to the "Edit Issue" permission, I really don't see any point in having a special permission to simply delete a Test step.

Just caught this thread.

As an admin to our Jira application. I would prefer that Issues and its control are treated seperatley to the control of test steps.

Ideally Test Steps should have its own set of permissions as per an issue.

This woudl allow for better control and flexability.

Thanks

Ideally it's own permisson, however "Edit" is more suitable, definetly not "Delete" issue.

Hello All,

This issue has been fixed under our latest release of Zephyr For JIRA 2.5.1 which was launched on 08-12-2014.

https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/com.thed.zephyr.je/versions

This version is supported with JIRA 5.2 - 6.3.5. Update to the latest version will resolve this issue of deleting the test steps permission.

Thank you.

Kind Regards,

Bibek 

 

@Bibek, can you explain please how this issue was solved in 2.5.1? Specifically, what change was made in 2.5.1 – what permissions are now required for deleting a test step?

I just tested this and it does work for us… JIRA v6.2.2.   (Edit Permission is the only permission needed , not delete)

 

Thank YOU!

Hi S Stack,

In 2.5.1 the user who has edit issue permission can modify the test case (edit/delete test steps).Delete issue permission is no more mandatory to delete the test steps what was earlier implemented in 2.5 and proved to be inconvenient to some of the teams.In 2.5.1 the permission schema is again switched back to what it was earlier.

Thanks and Regards,

Bibek 

 

Bibek, thank you. I've tested 2.5.1 and 'delete test step' works as expected.

Would have loved to have seen a sentence or two explaining this fix in the 2.5.1 Release Notes! Then we could have addressed this problem back in August.

Suggest an answer

Log in or Sign up to answer
How to earn badges on the Atlassian Community

How to earn badges on the Atlassian Community

Badges are a great way to show off community activity, whether you’re a newbie or a Champion.

Learn more
Community showcase
Published May 30, 2018 in Marketplace Apps

Three tips for boosting your board's efficiency with Story Maps

Trello is one of the most effective tools for driving your sprints. It's customizable for every Agile team and product owners and Scrum masters (SM) love it. However, Agile teams often struggle with:...

824 views 2 9
Read article

Atlassian User Groups

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find a group

Connect with like-minded Atlassian users at free events near you!

Find my local user group

Unfortunately there are no AUG chapters near you at the moment.

Start an AUG

You're one step closer to meeting fellow Atlassian users at your local meet up. Learn more about AUGs

Groups near you