How to extend the CommentManager?

[Andreas Rehbehn]

The classes I fetch from ComponentAccessor, is that always a new instance or an instance that JIRA already uses at that moment?

Because I want to extend the CommentManager, is that doable by changing the factory or do I have to instatiate it with all it´s dependencies in my script?

[Andreas Ebert]

ComponentAccessor returns the singleton instance for each class. Never a new one. Also, it is hard-coded in JIRA's source (see ContainerRegistrar) which implementation for each interface is returned. You can't easily extend that. See also this thread.

You also shouldn't instantiate any component yourself. That probably won't work correctly.

[Andreas Rehbehn]

Ok, thank you, so the only option I see right now is to wrap the CommentManager in my own class to add functionality, which isn´t a good option either.

[Jamie Echlin [Adaptavist]]

What are you actually trying to do?

[Andreas Rehbehn]

I have some extra features which I want to put in a class, because I use it in multiple files:
getInternalComments() and getExternalComments()

I could put them in closures or capsulate them in a class, so I wrote a MyCommentManager class which gets the CommentManager as dependency and fetches me the comments I want.